Complexity’s bad reputation is rooted in its very name: cum-plectere, to weave together. The parts of a complex system cannot be separated; they merge with one another, creating new meanings and new scenarios each time. Edgar Morin, who devoted much of his work to complexity, began precisely here: complexus is that which is woven together (Morin, 1990).

The term ‘complicated’ is different: cum-plicare, to fold together. Something that has been folded can more easily be unfolded, and perhaps even ironed.

Etymology alone proves nothing, but it already suggests the difference: unravelling an entanglement is almost impossible, whereas unfolding something complicated is a task within our reach. Dave Snowden and Mary Boone made this the heart of a model for decision-makers in organisations: in complicated contexts, a relationship between cause and effect exists and an expert can find it through analysis; in complex ones, it can only be recognised in retrospect. They therefore invite us to let the "right choices" emerge through exploration and testing. (Snowden and Boone, 2007).

The strain of complexity

We belong to far more complex systems than we imagine. Wherever there are people, there is a complex system, with dynamics that are hard to predict. The weather is a complex system; a company is a complex system. The weather, incidentally, shows just how inadequate knowing the rules can be: in the 1960s, Edward Lorenz discovered that a system governed by entirely deterministic equations can still become unpredictable, because tiny differences in initial conditions produce vastly different outcomes (Lorenz, 1963).

To keep a complex system under control, we would have to monitor an enormous number of parameters, including environmental contingencies, and track them in real time to catch the fluctuations of every element within it.

Unfortunately, our brain has a limited capacity for what it can handle in a short space of time: dealing with several things at once is almost impossible. This is why we readily give up in the face of complexity, even to the point of denying it. One myth has it that we do this to save glucose: a difficult task increases the brain’s energy consumption by just a few percentage points, often less than 5% (Raichle and Gusnard, 2002). What the brain tries to save is effort, which it perceives as a cost, and in experiments, people given a choice consistently avoid tasks that demand more mental effort (Kool et al., 2010). So, from its well-protected box, it shouts things at us like ‘come on, enough already, let’s keep it simple’.

Making it complicated means simplifying it

What we do, then, is take something complex and limit its variables until analysing it becomes bearable: we turn the complex into something complicated. Now we can begin to think we might be able to solve it.

The brain is more comfortable with a specific goal: it can exercise selective attention and concentration, it can start ‘doing’, and meanwhile what psychologists call a sense of agency grows — the feeling that we are the ones making things happen. I have my wall, I have my hammer, I can start hammering, so I am making progress: I am incredibly strong and incredibly active.

However strenuous it may be, we have in fact simplified things: something that was previously difficult to think through has now become difficult to act upon. A good step forward.

Staying with the complicated while accounting for the complex

How aware are you of the system? We can choose to simplify without denying, yet we need only poke our noses inside organisations to see that the opposite often happens: once the complicated project has been mapped out, the nuances of complexity are erased from the equation. A selective blindness arises, and with it the risk of fixating on a few variables and constantly seeking new ways to act on them: new tools, new hammers, perhaps some explosives. Psychology knows this blindness well. In the famous experiment by Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris, about half the participants, busy counting passes of a ball, failed to see a person dressed as a gorilla walk through the scene (Simons and Chabris, 1999).

It happens, for example, when we strive to improve a process without taking account of the people who carry it out. The numbers say we are too slow, and we fail to consider that people are working in a state of perpetual stress: the solutions ‘be faster’ or ‘let’s work overtime’ are the bigger hammer, while the person is losing the strength to wield it. Here too, the data are on their side: beyond a certain threshold of weekly hours, output for each additional hour falls sharply, for reasons ranging from cognitive load to injuries and absenteeism. (Pencavel, 2015).

Now let’s really simplify

In my view, simplification needs to inhabit complexity; it needs a fluidity of thought that flows over what happens from moment to moment: ready to grasp a variable as it appears, ready to take it on, ready to assess it from the most systemic perspective possible and, above all, ready to let it go without becoming attached. This is, after all, what Snowden and Boone recommend for complex contexts: first probe, then observe what emerges, then respond.

In organisations, this happens when a process generates friction, for example when someone periodically finds themselves having to rework what they have done. We can intervene by asking them to be more careful and precise, we can check the route by which information reaches them, we can involve other departments to improve the flow upstream. At some point, we might discover that the information cannot reach them any better than it already does, and that their reworking is a consequence of the structure before it is a consequence of the person. William Edwards Deming, one of the fathers of total quality, estimated from experience that 94% of problems belong to the system, and are therefore the responsibility of those who run it, and only 6% stem from specific causes (Deming, 1986). At that point, either we let the variable go, or we move to an adjacent system: that of senior management, who have the power to intervene in the structure itself. Usually this choice is labelled too much effort, and the reworking is accepted.

Keeping our eyes on complexity without denying it helps us maintain a holistic approach. In an organisation, for example, this means accepting that we must step beyond the boundaries of our own department, aware that we are part of a wider system. By accepting this, we put ourselves in a position to have a much broader impact.

Inhabiting complexity is a matter of acceptance: letting it flow and managing its expressions as needs arise, knowing that the system might shortly reconfigure itself, rendering our intervention pointless or requiring an even more substantial one.

In the end, it happens in families too. You tell your daughter off, expecting her to calm down; she gets even angrier, and her mother, who has meanwhile come home from work, loses it too. Everything deteriorates and forces you to change your approach until things return to equilibrium. We live in a world dense with complexity: let’s embrace it.

Or equip ourselves with a truly enormous hammer and a great deal of strength.
We just have to choose.

References

Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of the Crisis. MIT Press, p. 315.

Kool, W., McGuire, J. T., Rosen, Z. B. e Botvinick, M. M. (2010). Decision making and the avoidance of cognitive demand. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 139(4), 665-682.

Lorenz, E. N. (1963). Deterministic nonperiodic flow. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 20(2), 130-141.

Morin, E. (1990). Introduction à la pensée complexe. ESF. Edizione italiana: Introduzione al pensiero complesso, Sperling & Kupfer, 1993.

Pencavel, J. (2015). The productivity of working hours. The Economic Journal, 125(589), 2052-2076.

Raichle, M. E. e Gusnard, D. A. (2002). Appraising the brain's energy budget. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 99(16), 10237-10239.

Simons, D. J. e Chabris, C. F. (1999). Gorillas in our midst: Sustained inattentional blindness for dynamic events. Perception, 28(9), 1059-1074.

Snowden, D. J. e Boone, M. E. (2007). A leader's framework for decision making. Harvard Business Review, novembre 2007.