esFor almost twenty years I worked in IT, a world where things, at least on the surface, either work or they do not. A server responds or it does not; a network is reachable or it is not. During those years I went through quite a few transformations: digital, agile, cultural. Each arrived with its own vocabulary, with new roles and with the promise that this time would be different. After a few months, almost invariably, things were surprisingly similar to how we had left them. The words changed. The way we were together changed much less. 

For a long time I wondered why change in organisations is so often wanted so much and achieved so little. The usual explanations — a lack of will, of method, of a genuine sponsor — have always seemed only partly true to me. They explain why a particular transformation stalls. They do not explain why it stalls in such similar ways in vastly different contexts, often led by people who genuinely believe in what they are doing. 

A way of understanding this that I had not considered came from an article published this year in Organizational Dynamics, by Udayan Dhar, Richard Boyatzis and other researchers associated with the Coaching Research Lab at Case Western Reserve University (Dhar et al., 2026). The authors begin with a paradox that anyone working in a company will recognise: productivity is at record levels, while engagement continues to fall. According to Gallup, the proportion of engaged workers worldwide fell from 23% in 2023 to 21% in 2024, with the sharpest decline among managers themselves (Gallup, 2025). 

Their hypothesis runs through the body. When attention is directed towards metrics, targets and problems to solve, a network the authors call analytical, the Task Positive Network, predominates in the brain, accompanied by activation of the sympathetic nervous system — in other words, the stress response. This is the state that allows us to concentrate and get things done, and no organisation could do without it. This network, however, tends to inhibit the Default Mode Network, which the authors call empathetic: the one associated with openness to new ideas, attention to people and emotions, and the capacity to imagine one's possible self. The two networks behave as antagonists: when one rises, the other falls. 

The authors themselves frankly acknowledge that the move from an individual brain to the culture of an entire organisation is a hypothesis, not an established finding. I take it for what it is: an image, supported by some evidence, that precisely describes something I have seen happen many times. 

The article's most uncomfortable point concerns people's development. For decades, the authors observe, training, coaching and development programmes have been designed and evaluated in the service of performance. The development conversation placed within the annual appraisal, perhaps immediately after the rating, is the clearest example: the person on the receiving end understands perfectly well that they are being helped to grow so that they will deliver more. A functional magnetic resonance imaging study cited in the article shows how questions about one's ideal self and those about one's real self — about what is wrong and needs correcting — engage the brain in different ways (Jack, Passarelli and Boyatzis, 2023). The title of that study already says a great deal: when fixing problems kills personal development. 

I believe this phenomenon deserves a name. I would call it transformation on held breath. It is what happens when an organisation asks people to learn, change and imagine, while keeping them permanently in the physiological state that makes all of this harder. We hold our breath to reach the deadline, the release, the end of the quarter, and promise ourselves we will think about breathing afterwards. In a culture that measures only performance, however, afterwards almost never comes. Transformation on held breath has some recognisable signs: the vocabulary of change coexists with the same old metrics, development comes as a reward for those who have already delivered or as a corrective for those who have delivered less, and time devoted to reflection is felt to be time taken away from real work. 

Dhar and his colleagues are not proposing that we abandon performance. Organisations have to function, and the authors say so clearly. Instead, they suggest placing a culture of development alongside the culture of performance, with equal standing and processes of its own: development conversations separated in time and space from appraisal conversations, tools such as 360° feedback used to foster growth rather than to judge, and a twofold question to ask before every decision. How will this affect the organisation's performance? How will it affect the development of the people who work there? The two questions should carry equal weight. In my experience, the second almost always comes later, if it comes at all. 

There is, however, a level that no separation of processes can reach on its own. Michael Spayd, who has worked for years on applying integral theory to agile transformations (Spayd and Madore, 2020), is developing what he calls systemic alchemy. His starting point is anthropological. We are social animals, shaped over an immensely long time by a deep need to belong, because exclusion from the group once meant putting survival at risk. This is why, Spayd writes, our consciousness became attuned to the voice of the tribe, to its rules and expectations, often before we had even developed a clear sense of our individuality. Anyone wishing to contribute to systemic change should therefore first become aware of the systems they already carry within them: family, culture of origin, work. These systems can obstruct the change we would like to support, but they are also a source of strength and connection (Spayd, 2025). 

Read alongside the article by Dhar and his colleagues, this line of thought shifts the question. The problem is not only that organisations keep us holding our breath. It is that, after years, holding our breath becomes one of the conditions of belonging. We learn that the safest way to remain inside is to deliver without stopping and without asking too many questions. Here the distinction between corporate culture and corporate cult, recently discussed in various quarters, ceases to be theoretical: a culture begins to resemble a cult when belonging demands conformity and critical thought is mistaken for disloyalty. When I left IT, I realised that the habit of rushing from one deadline to the next, without ever really stopping, had come away with me. Changing my surroundings was not enough to stop holding my breath. 

This is also why, in my work as a coach, I speak of Conscious Agility. It is not a new framework: it is a way of giving this thing a name, the individual and collective capacity to move between concentration and openness while knowing which of the two we are in, without confusing one with the other and without pretending we can inhabit both at the same time. An agility unaware of its own state becomes mere speed. 

I am left with some questions I do not know how to settle. Can time for development really be protected when the quarter is going badly, or is that precisely when we discover what culture an organisation truly has? After years in which development has been an instrument of performance, how long does it take for people to stop suspecting it? And those who, like me, support people and teams while being paid by those same organisations — how far can we remain in the service of development, and how far do we risk, unwittingly, becoming another instrument of performance? 

Perhaps transformation begins less with changing things and more with learning to breathe again: with allowing ourselves, alone and together, the time to stay with these thoughts, dense as they are.

References

Boyatzis, R. E., Smith, M. L. e Beveridge, A. J. (2013). Coaching with compassion: Inspiring health, well-being, and development in organizations. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 49(2), 153–178. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886312462236 

Dhar, U., Boyatzis, R., Smith, M., Taylor, S. e Van Oosten, E. (2026). Creating an organizational culture of development to complement a culture of performance. Organizational Dynamics, 55, 101251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orgdyn.2026.101251 

Gallup (2025). State of the Global Workplace: 2025 Report. Gallup Press. 

Jack, A. I., Passarelli, A. M. e Boyatzis, R. E. (2023). When fixing problems kills personal development: fMRI reveals conflict between Real and Ideal selves. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 17, 1128209. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2023.1128209 

Spayd, M. K. (2025, 13 maggio). A path to systemic alchemy: Understanding the Self in the context of Systems. Michael Spayd / The Systemic Way. https://michaelspayd839113.substack.com/p/a-path-to-systemic-alchemy 

Spayd, M. K. e Madore, M. (2020). Agile Transformation: Using the Integral Agile Transformation Framework to Think and Lead Differently. Addison-Wesley.